Black Lotus - Illustration by Steven Belledin

Black Lotus | Illustration by Steven Belledin

As you may have heard, the now-defunct Rules Committee banned certain cards from Commander, citing concerns that โ€œfast manaโ€ cards contribute to problematic and unfun gameplay patterns. These cards can create an environment where some players accelerate their game plan to an overwhelming degree, disrupting the balance and enjoyment for others.

But what exactly is fast mana, and which cards are at risk of being banned in Commander or other MTG formats that WotC might consider intervening in?

Letโ€™s find out!

What Is Fast Mana in MTG?

Mox Amber - Illustration by Steven Belledin

Mox Amber | Illustration by Steven Belledin

In Magic: The Gathering, โ€œfast manaโ€ usually refers to very cheap spells or permanents that allow you to generate extra mana beyond your usual land drops to be used immediately, especially in the early turns of the game.

This mana is commonly used to play spells that put you way ahead in the game, and in most cases, lock up an early win. For these and other reasons, fast mana is prized in formats like Commander or Cube Draft, where it speeds up gameplay, though itโ€™s sometimes restricted or banned in competitive formats due to its game-breaking potential.

Itโ€™s also worth mentioning that this list isnโ€™t Commander-only cards, so with that in mind, you may now have a pretty good idea of what will be at the top.

Honorable Mentions

Bloom TenderSelvala, Explorer Returned

Some cards have the potential to add a lot of mana, but they arenโ€™t included as part of this list as they're too slow to accomplish the feat. Bloom Tender and Selvala, Explorer Returned, for example, excel at ramping ahead in green decks. Still, since they arenโ€™t immediate, they donโ€™t fully qualify as fast mana. Perhaps the greatest distinction between โ€œfast manaโ€ and general โ€œrampโ€ is the ability to use that mana right away.

Mox Tantalite

Mox Tantalite is too slow for the burst of mana you get when this comes off suspend.

Big-mana producers like Food Chain, Sacrifice, and Carpet of Flowers can do quite a bit, but they require extra investment.

#27. Crystal Vein

Crystal Vein

At the cost of sacrificing it, you can add 2 mana on your first turn with Crystal Vein. While that scenario may not happen very often, it certainly pushes you ahead to cast broken spells ahead of schedule.

#26. Tinder Wall

Tinder Wall

I like to think of Tinder Wall as a green Rite of Flame since it's basically what this green creature does.

#25. Irencrag Feat

Irencrag Feat

It may seem a bit โ€œexpensiveโ€ for a ritual, but it's a critical piece in some decks that want to cast a finisher spell during a single turn. Common targets include Etali, Primal Conqueror or Muxus, Goblin Grandee. A similar card to this red sorcery is Geosurge, but aside from being more restrictive in terms of what you can cast with it, itโ€™s considerably harder to cast outside of a mono-red deck.

#24. Mox Amber

Mox Amber

Since youโ€™re limited to adding mana based on the legendary creatures or planeswalkers you control, thereโ€™ll be very few chances you get fast mana with Mox Amber. That said, if your commander costs just 1 mana, as Tamiyo, Inquisitive Student does, youโ€™ll have no issues ramping ahead of the game or potentially playing multiple spells on turn 1.

#23. Mox Opal

Mox Opal

Essentially, Mox Opal lets you speed ahead in the game by providing free, flexible mana very early in decks that can quickly pile up artifacts on the battlefield like affinity or artifact commander builds. Due to this, it was banned in the early days of Modern and relegated to Legacy and Vintage.

#22. Lotus Bloom

Lotus Bloom

Like Mox Tantalite, Lotus Bloom is an artifact that can give you mana after an initial wait. The main difference is that this one adds more than just 1 mana, and you can wait for it to resolve if you draw it in your initial hand to go off with your combo on turn 4.

#21. Lotus Petal

Lotus Petal

In most decks, Lotus Petal works as a one-time mana accelerator for combo and storm decks to pull off their kills ahead of schedule. Iโ€™ve most often seen this in Legacy, where archetypes like Reanimator capitalize on the temporary burst of mana, but it's also had its time in Pauper.

#20. Rite of Flame

Rite of Flame

Similar to Dark Ritual, Rite of Flame adds extra mana for just a mere investment of 1. That said, this sorcery has the potential to add more mana if other copies of it are in someone's graveyard, making it hard to justify which one deserves to be higher than the other.

#19. Pyretic Ritual + Desperate Ritual + Cabal Ritual

Pyretic Ritual and Desperate Ritual are both fantastic red cards for ramping up and enabling one-turn kills in combo decks. Cabal Ritual is their black counterpart, except this black instant is slightly better once you have threshold as it adds more mana.

#18. Seething Song

Seething Song

Now, if youโ€™re looking to add even more mana, Seething Song is the real card you should be looking for. Usually, combo decks go turn 1 Rite of Flame into Desperate Ritual into Seething Song to add an immense amount of mana for an explosive finisher, sure, but also to add up a storm count for cards like Empty the Warrens or Grapeshot.

#17. _____ Goblin

_____ Goblin

You know a card is weird when it's banned in every sanctioned format, including Vintage. Of course it's still available in Commander, but due to how complex the sticker mechanic is, they decided to get rid of _____ Goblin everywhere else. It also has the potential to add more mana than what you used to cast it, mainly acting as a Seething Song with legs.

#16. Elvish Spirit Guide + Simian Spirit Guide

Elvish Spirit GuideSimian Spirit Guide

Both Elvish Spirit Guide and Simian Spirit Guide are critical pieces in decks that want to add as much mana as possible with little investment. I first saw these in Goblin Charbelcher decks, but they're also used along with other fast mana cards in many other decks, like Mono-Red Stompy in Legacy.

#15. Lion's Eye Diamond

Lion's Eye Diamond

Iโ€™ve seen Lion's Eye Diamond in decks like The Perfect Storm in Legacy or Memory Jar decks where you can bypass the slight drawback of discarding your hand. With that in mind and the right knowledge on using it, this 0-mana artifactโ€™s a powerhouse for pulling off crazy combos, usually along with Mind's Desire.

#14. Grim Monolith

Grim Monolith

Grim Monolith was one of the first cards I realized is a bit too much for certain Commander decks due to its potential of adding infinite mana when paired with the likes of Power Artifact.

#13. Mishra's Workshop

Mishra's Workshop

Mishra's Workshop is an extremely niche card as it only works with artifact spells, but it's incredibly broken with that card type. After all, a turn 1 Workshop puts you just 1 mana away from casting The One Ring.

#12. Orcish Lumberjack

Orcish Lumberjack

Orcish Lumberjack is the only card on this list that doesnโ€™t add mana right away once it's on the battlefield. Still, for only 1 mana, you can add at least 5 more by turn 2, which is immense considering that youโ€™ll be just 2 mana short of casting an Etali, Primal Conqueror.

#11. Chrome Mox + Mox Diamond

Mox Diamond and Chrome Mox are very similar in what they do as they both act as the moxen from the Power Nine at the low cost of exiling a card of a required type from your hand.

#10. Mana Vault

Mana Vault

Mana Vault is excellent for quick, explosive starts, but youโ€™ll want a plan for dealing with it once it's tapped or youโ€™ll end up paying for that boost in life points. Luckily, some cards like Tezzeret the Seeker can search for this artifact and put it onto the battlefield, but more importantly, untap it on each of your turns without investing any additional mana.

#9. Dark Ritual

Dark Ritual

Iโ€™ve asked many players what cards they think are considered โ€œfast-manaโ€ and more often than not, the main card they mention is Dark Ritual. For a mere 1 mana, you can play many oppressive cards ahead of schedule. From playing a Liliana of the Veil on turn 1 or just slamming a passive card draw source like Phyrexian Arena, this black instant is critical to accomplish those feats. Of course, it's a matter of getting creative with it, but in a format where you can play a Necropotence, itโ€™s a no-brainer to run this cheap instant.

#8. Ancient Tomb + City of Traitors

Ancient TombCity of Traitors

I have a hard time trying to figure out which of these is better as they have drawbacks that make them difficult to play in certain decks. Still, Ancient Tomb and City of Traitors are my favorite fast lands of all time, and make certain Eternal format strategies viable on their own.

#7. Channel

Channel

The name of this card should be โ€œTurn 2 Emrakul, the Aeons Tornโ€ (or insert any big Eldrazi of your choosing). Of course, you can even cast Channel on turn 1 with the help of other cards from the list, so itโ€™s no wonder why itโ€™s banned in many Eternal formats and available only in Vintage as a restricted card.

#6. Dockside Extortionist

Dockside Extortionist

Dockside Extortionist was banned from Commander, as you can create multiple Treasure tokens for just 2 mana. The problem wasnโ€™t only that you can ramp ahead with ease once it's resolved, but also that many decks exploit its enter the battlefield effect to retrigger it over and over to generate infinite mana, among other incidental effects that may occur from sacrificing artifacts.

#5. Mana Crypt

Mana Crypt

While the drawback of using a Mana Crypt may seem high at first, it becomes negligible in formats like Commander. That was one of the reasons behind its ban, as it can enable many explosive starts in competitive versions of the format. That said, outside of that โ€œniche,โ€ I really have a hard time seeing it in kitchen table matches.

#4. Jeweled Lotus

Jeweled Lotus

The last fast mana card banned from Commander in September 2024 was Jeweled Lotus. While banning all three pieces (and a bird that no format enjoyed playing against) caused a major uproar in the community, I wouldnโ€™t disagree with banning just one of these while keeping the rest alive, Dockside Extortionist being the most reasonable option. Still, casting your commander on turn 1 can quickly make entire boards one-sided, so it's about the pros and cons of this decision.

#3. Power Nine Moxes

Mox Emerald, Mox Jet, Mox Pearl, Mox Ruby, and Mox Sapphire form the vast majority of the Power Nine, and theyโ€™re considered among the best cards you could open during a Vintage Cube. Theyโ€™re without a doubt some of the best fast mana cards ever printed.

#2. Black Lotus

Black Lotus

How come Black Lotus isnโ€™t the number one spot? Well, the answer is that thereโ€™s one mana rock that adds 1 less mana but at a steady pace.

#1. Sol Ring

Sol Ring

Look, if Stephen A. Smith thinks Sol Ring is better than Black Lotus, who am I to tell him heโ€™s wrong? More importantly, great minds like Jon Finkel also back up his train of thought!

Jokes aside, this card has been the face of Commander if the format ever needed one, and it seems that it would never see the rusty cages of the ban prison for the format.

Best Fast Mana Payoffs

Cards that are win conditions on their own, like Brain Freeze or Grapeshot, like most of the fast mana cards listed above. Others like Trinisphere or Blood Moon aim to be cast on turn 1 to shut down other decks.

Big colorless spells like Karn Liberated and Ugin, the Spirit Dragon are good targets to accelerate out, since they provide steady advantage over time, and colorless planeswalkers like this don't care about the color restrictions on most fast mana effects.

What Is the Difference Between Fast Mana and Ramp?

Fast mana usually refers to effects that provide immediate, extra mana through sources like Sol Ring or Dark Ritual, enabling powerful plays early on without increasing the number of lands you have in play. In contrast, ramp involves adding more lands to the battlefield, usually through spells like Cultivate or Rampant Growth that increase a playerโ€™s long-term mana resources gradually. Fast mana provides an immediate mana advantage, while ramp builds a steady, enduring mana base over time through lands and other mana sources like mana dorks and mana rocks.

Some of the very best cards, like Sol Ring, can work as both.

Wrap Up

Sol Ring (Commander Collection Green) - Illustration by Joseph Meehan

Sol Ring | Illustration by Joseph Meehan

While fast mana can certainly fit into various themes and deck archetypes, one undeniable truth remains: Having more mana than your opponents in the early game is key to securing victory. Because of this, WotC has made a โ€œcommitmentโ€ not to print cards like Dockside Extortionist again, as theyโ€™re considered a โ€œmistakeโ€ due to the proven impact they pose on multiplayer formats.

What do you think? Is this list complete, or would you make it broader by including cards like Food Chain? Let us know in the comments or on Discord!

As always, thanks for reading up until now, and if you want to stay on top of our MTG news and articles, remember to follow us on social media to never miss a thing!

Take care, and see you next time!

Follow Draftsim for awesome articles and set updates:

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *