Last updated on September 13, 2023
Doubling Season | Illustration by Richard Wright
The matchmaking system in MTG Arena is a confusing thing. You sit down at your computer, pick what queue you want to play in, and decide which deck you want to use for the game. A few moments later, you’re matched against somebody that the game has decided is your equal and you start slinging spells.
We take this whole process for granted for the most part and don’t really question what it is or what we’d do without it. But I imagine you’re at least curious about how the matchmaking system chooses your opponents, right? Let’s talk about it.
Keeping track of how the system picks your opponent can get a little tricky, but once you break it down and take a closer look, things start to make sense. MTG Arena’s matchmaking relies on the ranking system to decide your opponents, and then breaks down a little more from there .
Demystify | Illustration by Véronique Meignaud
What is MMR?
Under the surface of the rank Arena gives you, you’ve got an “MMR” (matchmaking rank) which is assigned to you based on your gameplay. There are three different MMRs that MTGA keeps track of as you play: Open Play MMR, Constructed MMR, and Limited MMR.
These help to keep you playing against the “right” opponent regardless of which deck you choose. If you’re really good at Constructed but bad at drafting, you won’t have to worry about getting stomped in Limited while you’re busy mopping the floor in the Constructed scene. Ranked formats use both your Limited and Constructed MMR respective to whichever format you’re playing, so you’re safe from any skill level mix-ups.
Matchmaking in Mythic
Ok, so we’ve gone over how your rank impacts your pool of opponents, but you’re likely asking: “What about once you hit Mythic and you don’t have any steps to climb like in the lower ranks?” My answer to you is that, well, that’s why MMR exists.
Once you get to Mythic, your MMR takes over completely and you’ll notice that, instead of being in stages of Mythic, you’ll have a percentage that shows you roughly where you are in the rank compared to other players. This percentage is calculated by your MMR and tells you how close you are to the Mythic leaderboard. For example, if you’re at 78%, that means you only have another 22% left to climb before earning a spot on the top of the top.
The Mythic leaderboard itself is comprised of 1500 spots, all of which are decided by comparing Mythic-ranked players’ MMR. Naturally, this also affects matchmaking, and you shouldn’t see too many people that are far from where you are. It’s also important to know that players can share the same MMR, meaning two players have the same rank. So, don’t be too surprised if both you and your opponent are ranked at #876 on the ladder.
Matchmaking for Limited
This all makes sense for Constructed, but what about Limited? Well, let me tell ya, there’s not much of a difference.
You’ll switch from your rank and MMR in Constructed to your rank and MMR in Limited if you jump into the ranked queue for draft. Your current win/loss ratio is also thrown into the mix.
The calculations that go into choosing your opponents will be the same as they were in Constructed, with the added bonus that you don’t have to worry about facing off against a deck that’s 6-0 when you’ve only been able to go 3-2 in your current run. You’re more likely to face off against an opponent with a similar record and skill level with all three of these benchmarks in place.
Checks and Balances | Illustration by David A. Cherry
Matchmaking for Open Play Queues
Moving past the gears and cogs of the ranked system, let’s chat about the regular “Play” queue. Deck strength matchmaking is used in the Best-of-One (BO1) Play queue. Deck weight is a system that gives a rating to each card in your deck, resulting in an overall score. This score, combined with your unranked MMR and number of games played, is used to find opponents that are the best match for you.
Brawl also uses deck weight matchmaking and recently had an update to the weight of certain commanders for matchmaking. Because of the fix, laid-back decks should have an easier time finding each other and evading the big, bad, scary competitive decks.
Developer's Note: Omnath, Locus of Creation will remain playable in Historic Brawl, but will be weighted alongside the other more competitive Commanders (e.g. Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God, Niv-Mizzet Reborn, etc.)
Deck strength isn’t considered for your matches outside of the BO1 Open Play queue and Brawl. In Traditional, you’re only going to have your Open Play MMR affect your pool of opponents. In Traditional Draft, the game will only use your win/loss record, while your Limited MMR will be used in Sealed along with your win/loss ratio.
Last One Standing | Illustration by Svetlin Velinov
Event matchmaking, whether for Constructed events or special events like Momir, Pauper, Singleton, etc., only use your win/loss ratio. This means that most players in those event queues are more likely to be using a deck that’s recently topped a big tournament or a deck that sits at the top of the metagame. So, if you’re ever wondering why you see so many top tier decks running around in Constructed events while you’re using a clever homebrew, it’s because there’s no extra check or balance in the matchmaking system.
This could be pretty infuriating if you didn’t know about this, which is why it’s probably a decent idea to check up on how the matchmaking systems work before putting on your tinfoil hat and writing conspiracies. That hasn’t exactly stopped the “shuffler truthers” that are out there, though. So… you do you, I guess?
Matchmaking for Mythic Qualifiers
On a similar note to event matchmaking, you might be wondering about Mythic Qualifier matchmaking. While I have yet to see anything that breaks down the matchmaking system for those events, it’s more likely than not just using your win/loss ratio the same way any other Constructed event would. If you think about it, the players in a Mythic Qualifier are probably already within a relatively similar skill level since they were skilled enough to get invited.
Exploits and Speculation – Is it Rigged? Broken? Does it Suck?
We’ve been through a lot here, and I know what you’re thinking, even if you don’t know you’re thinking it: “Is there a way to exploit the matchmaking system?” Well, that sure is a swell question because as far as I know and have found, the closest you can get to exploiting it is trying to finagle with deck weight matchmaking in Open Play. The only issue there is that you probably don’t want to exploit Open Play and would rather exploit Ranked. If that’s the case, tough luck.
While there is no way likely to exploit matchmaking, there are plenty of those who hold their own beliefs about extra factors in the matchmaking system that Wizards might not be telling us about. It’s entirely up to you as to whether or not you want to believe them, but if you hop on Reddit and dig around for a bit, you’re bound to find conspiracy threads scattered about. Some of the most common ones I’ve found tend to experiment with Open Play, trying to crack the code on other factors that the game looks at with each card it scores in deck weight matchmaking.
Have You Found Your Match?
Tell us, have you found the matchmaking method behind your preferred queue? Is it not what you thought it would be or is it exactly what you expected? We’re all ears in the comments if you have anything to say or questions to ask.
Out of Bounds | Illustration by Dmitry BurmakFollow Draftsim for awesome articles and set updates: