Last updated on December 15, 2025
The Moment | Illustration by Patrik Hell
It’s no secret that Magic is an expensive hobby, which is why MTG players are always on the lookout for the best way to get new cards. While we all know buying Magic singles is the most reliable way to get our money’s worth, it’s hard not to feel the allure of opening a booster pack. There’s a nagging “what if?” in the back of our minds that we might just pull the card we want in a much cheaper way than paying for it outright. Enter Boxed.gg.
Boxed.gg offers an alternative way to scratch that “what if?” itch besides opening Magic boosters. Boxed.gg allows you to open curated boxes with a chance to score some great Magic cards. The price of each box varies, as do its contents and your odds of grabbing a great pull.
Of course, it’s smart to be cautious about sites like this. There’s already an uncomfortable overlap between cracking packs and gambling, and sites like Boxed.gg can blur the line even further. I walk you through the Boxed experience and let you know my thoughts so you can make an informed decision about trying it out.
What Is Boxed.gg?
Box of Free-Range Goblins | Illustration by Chris Seaman
Boxed.gg is a site that allows you to open custom-made loot boxes for Magic, Pokémon, and One Piece.
Boxed.gg has two main ways to get Magic cards. The first is through their randomized boxes. You pay to open a box, and you get a single card from it.
Boxes vary in several ways. First, there’s the contents. Each box has a list of cards that you can possibly get and a rundown of your chances of getting a specific card. Second is what they call a box’s “spice” ranking. Boxes are ranked on three tiers of “spice.” The higher the tier, the greater the risk/reward ratio is for a given box.
The final factor is the box’s price. Boxes are priced depending on the price of your potential pulls and your likelihood of getting something valuable. Boxes with higher spice ratings therefore tend to be a bit cheaper to open, but this is because you have a <1% chance of opening one of the good cards from inside it. Conversely, boxes with a lower spice ranking where you have a higher percentage chance of opening a good card cost more to open, though this still doesn’t guarantee you a good card.
To test it out, I opened a “max spice” box called CEDH Essentials. The box has an Ancient Tomb as its cover picture, a card that you have a 0.05% chance of opening. While there are plenty of cEDH staples in this box, your chances of actually landing one are pretty low, as described by the spice ranking, and it’s clearly shown below where you open the box.
To open the box, I paid 289 gems, the equivalent of $2.89. I landed on a $0.59 Springleaf Drum.
Next, I decided to open a box with a slightly lower spice rating. Though this box was slightly more expensive to open ($3.33), I also got a better pull: a $2.34 Fatal Push. I feel it’s important to note that I was still very lucky to have gotten something that was almost worth what I paid to open this box.
I only had a 4% chance of getting the Fatal Push I opened from the “Masters of Modern I” box. It was 10 times more likely that opening this box would have landed me a $0.04 copy of Borrowed Grace instead.
Because of this, going forward, I won’t be showing the specific pulls I got from a given box. I don’t want my luck – or lack thereof – to cloud your judgment when evaluating this site. What matters more is the odds of a given pull, as listed beneath each box.
If you don’t feel like risking your money on boxes, there’s another option for you. Boxed.gg offers graded cards for a set price. The selection here is limited, and the marketplace doesn’t offer all the cards that are available in boxes.
The final way to get cards on Boxed.gg is to create your own box. To do this, you can search from a larger database of cards and add them as potential pulls. Then, you can create the odds you want for each pull. Each card costs around 17% more than its estimated value, multiplied by the odds of pulling it. So, a $20.96 Courageous Critters version of Jace, the Mind Sculptor with a 50% chance of being pulled adds $12.35 to the cost of opening the box.
This means, if you engage with Boxed.gg in the most economically responsible way possible, for every $100 you spend, you’ll likely walk away with about $85 worth of value. Is there a chance you get super lucky opening boxes and get more than your money’s worth? Absolutely. Is it a good chance? Not really.
The benefit to creating your own box is that it'll be offered to other users, and you get 3% of the overall gem cost added to your account if another user opens the box you created.
After you’ve collected some cards, and you want the physical copies, you can have them shipped to you. Just go to your collection page, select each card you want sent to you, and click withdraw. You’re then given a few options; you can either withdraw the gem value of the cards and use them to shop on the marketplace, or you can have the physical cards shipped to you.
Boxed.gg charges 550 gems ($5.50) to ship up to 15 cards. If you load up a predetermined number of gems, make sure you leave some to make sure you can actually ship yourself your cards. The smallest increment of gems you can purchase is 1,000 for $10, so you’ll end up having to put in some extra money if you run out of gems and just want to ship your cards. They also have special deals from time to time, and offer a discount on gems.
After your order has been withdrawn, it enters a pending phase. You’ll be notified when each of your cards has been verified by Boxed.gg and is ready to ship out. Once each card in the order has been assessed, you’ll receive a USPS tracking number. For cards pulled from boxes, it typically takes 2-4 weeks to arrive. For marketplace cards, you can expect a much shorter 3-10 day wait. I’ll tackle the reasons for this when I discuss my disclaimers.
Is Boxed.gg Worth It?
I’m going to give you a comprehensive rundown of my thoughts on Boxed.gg so you can make your own decision. That said, I'll start with some serious caveats that you should take into account before considering this site.
What to Know Before Using Boxed.gg
To be clear: This section isn’t meant to say nobody should use Boxed.gg. I think Boxed is an enjoyable experience for some customers; I prefer a more concrete approach to collecting cards, but I get the appeal. However, I think it’s very important that you understand what you’re getting yourself into before you start spending money on the site.
After opening my second Springleaf Drum in a row from a box, I wondered to myself: “How many of these do they have?” Over the two weeks since I initially tested Boxed.gg, the potential boxes have stayed consistent. There’s also no indication when picking cards for a custom box that there’s any sort of stock limitations on what you can include. To me, this indicates that Boxed.gg doesn’t actually have a stock of cards on hand but instead buys cards off the secondary market whenever a customer checks out.
This would also explain why it takes much longer to receive cards pulled from boxes than graded cards from the marketplace. Boxed seemingly has the graded cards on hand, whereas they’re likely waiting to receive shipments from sites like TCGplayer when you get cards from boxes.
After you withdraw your cards, before your order is shipped, your order needs to be processed. On the screen tracking this, you’re told how many of the cards you’ve ordered have been processed so far. Ten days after my initial order, zero of my 13 cards had been processed. This again seems to indicate that these aren’t cards that Boxed.gg has on hand, and they’re instead waiting for their orders to arrive before processing them and shipping them out.
Draftsim reached out to Boxed.gg on my behalf, and to their credit they immediately got back to us and confirmed shipping on my order. My cards arrived, safely packaged (which you can see in the “benefits” section), and within the estimated 2-4 weeks.
Given my positive experience with the site, I’d hope that this sort of delay on shipping isn't the norm, and that Boxed.gg is working to streamline the process.
Another important caveat to my recommendation of using Boxed.gg is that you need to take a very realistic attitude that the odds are not on your side that you’ll get your money’s worth before engaging with it. Not that they shy away from that fact, but if you’re someone that’s not fiscally responsible and blows their money on too many lottery tickets, then this site isn’t for you.
Still, the site probably does too good of a job teasing you that you could be a winner. To their credit, Boxed.gg offers a free daily reward. But the above images would suggest that I came very close to winning bigger than I actually did on my daily rewards and a box respectively. Of course, that isn’t really true. There’s no physical wheel spinning to determine what I get; my prize was determined the second I clicked the screen. It’s a common technique most famously used in mobile game apps to make you think you were very close to hitting the big bag of coins. This tricks your brain into thinking that your big score is just a spin away. Good thing that they only let you spin once a day and that it’s a free spin, otherwise this would be addictive and only getting one gem is kind of cruel.
There’s no age restriction for signing up and playing. All you need to do is provide an email address and create a username, and you’re ready to start buying gems. Boxed.gg has the setup to verify ID, and I think I’d be a lot more charitable to them if they used this built-in feature to impose an age limit on their site. That way, kids, who may not yet know how to be fiscally responsible, wouldn’t be exposed to potentially addictive features.
Boxed.gg clearly has a novel idea for digital booster packs, though the site is definitely designed with the usual features intended to hook people and keep them playing with the “potential” of an unlikely big payout. Again, this site is only intended for those who want to make the calculated risk of spending their money on a high-variance experience.
I’ve shared my thoughts in the past about how Magic toes a similar line with booster packs, but Boxed.gg takes things to another level. Imagine if instead of simply opening a booster pack and seeing what you got, the clerk at your LGS cracked the pack, showed you all the cool cards you “almost” got, then handed you a basic Swamp.
Another one of Boxed.gg’s features that I’m not fond of is the ability to “sell” any cards you pull back to the site. Each time you get a card, you get the chance to immediately exchange it for its gem value or keep it. While this might seem like a good way to get some value back from cards you don’t want, this usually just means you’re giving away money.
For example, say you spin a box for 400 gems and land on a bulk common worth 10. You probably don’t want it, and you also aren’t going to pay to have it shipped to you. So you sell it back. You’ve now essentially paid $3.90 for literally nothing. I’d much rather open packs and have bulk lying around for Pauper decks, drafting, or Commander boxing than pay to watch Magic cards spin around on my screen.
The Benefits of Boxed.gg
A major selling point of Boxed.gg is that it’s a novel experience. Booster packs are rarely as focused as many of the boxes on this site.
For instance, you aren’t likely to find a booster pack in Magic that is solely focused on 0-cost cards, like the “No Mana No Problem” box shown here. If you enjoy opening packs but want a smaller selection of potential cards to open with a tighter theme, Boxed.gg might be the site for you.
Another thing I appreciate about Boxed.gg is their transparency. Aside from listing the chances of getting any specific card from a box, Boxed also provides detailed information on how rolls from each box are determined. This information can be found on the “Provably Fair” tab listed next to each box you open.
Boxed.gg isn’t coming out and saying that you’ll win big, nor are they making it difficult to find your actual chances of winning. All the probabilities and information you need to make a decision are displayed in easy-to-find spaces.
Another nice thing about Boxed.gg is that they put the amount of money you pay for shipping into ensuring your cards are protected. Each card came in both a normal sleeve and a top loader, with the cards grouped into two sealed plastic bags. All of this was inside a hearty bubble mailer which was doubled over to ensure the cards weren’t moving around too much in transit.
I’m sure we’ve all experienced buying cards on the secondary market only to have them show up barely protected, despite having paid a decent amount for shipping. It’s nice to see that Boxed.gg actually spends their shipping fees to protect your cards, instead of spending the bare minimum and pocketing the rest.
Final Verdict
Strongbox Raider | Illustration by Craig J Spearing
If you think the Boxed.gg experience is for you, I don’t want to discourage you from using it. I got my cards, and I had some fun spinning the boxes. I just think it’s important to understand that this shouldn’t be seen as a potential way to make money, get excess value out of the money you spend, or even a viable alternative to buying singles. At the end of the day, Boxed.gg is essentially a lottery ball machine that spits out MTG cards. While I personally find that more fun than playing the lottery, it’s important to remember that’s what it is.
Have you used Boxed.gg? Did you have a similar experience to me? I’d love to hear your experience in the comments. You can also check out the Magic discussions we’re having on our Discord server.
Thank you for reading, and see you next time!
This post is sponsored by Boxed.gg. We will never work with a brand we don't love and trust, and by supporting them you also support Draftsim.
Follow Draftsim for awesome articles and set updates:
2 Comments
I’m curious if you have since tried to get cards shipped from boxed.gg again without using Draftsims name to ensure delivery.
If so did the experience go any better? The main complaint I see is being banned after requesting a shipping update.
Hey Gozo, unfortunately the writer has reported not using boxed.gg against after this review, so I can’t be of much help with this questions!
Add Comment