Last updated on November 21, 2026

Hela, Mistress of Darkness | Illustration by Bastien L. Deharme

Universes Beyond has perhaps been the most contentious topic of conversation among Magic players in the past several years, and for good reason. The blending of other intellectual properties into the game of Magic has done a lot to change the game, for better or for worse. However, recently it feels like things have fallen on the side of worse, as sets like Spider-Man, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, and The Hobbit have been abject disasters, with the most recent set, Star Trek, also being received rather poorly. However, there may be change on the horizon with the release of Darkhold Destiny in 2027, as Wizards of the Coast is altering their approach to Universes Beyond, and it may be exactly what Magic needs to ensure its future.

Aesthetics & Magic

Spirit Sorcerer | Illustration by RIFU

There have been a few main criticisms of Universes Beyond since it was introduced. The first is the issue of aesthetics. Magic: The Gathering is a high fantasy game. Yes it has many different planes with different takes and aesthetics of their own, but typically you can expect a healthy amount of goblins, swords, dragons, and well… magic. Exceptions to this are sets like Edge of Eternities which goes in the Sci-fi direction, although you can argue that sci-fi and fantasy are far more similar than they are different, and sets like Aetherdrift, Murders at Karlov Manor, and Outlaws of Thunder Junction. Affectionately referred to as hat sets due to the myriad of cliche headwear, these three in-universe sets were all criticised for their aesthetic shortcomings.

This is all to say that the aesthetic identity of Magic: The Gathering is very important to the game, and players notice when it’s tampered with or not paid enough attention in development. However, Universes Beyond completely ignores this concept. Afterall, it’s borrowed intellectual property, and it’s beholden to its own aesthetic before anything else. The end result of this varies from set to set. In the case of something like The Lord of the Rings, you can hardly tell a difference, as there is much shared territory between it and Magic, both being high fantasy settings.

And then there’s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Gooey pizza lands, 80s outfits, talking animals, etc. It starts to seem pretty offensive to the game of Magic when you have to play a card called Pizza Face, Gastromancer. This is certainly the worst of it, but the Marvel sets so far haven’t been much better. They’re set in New York City, and feature cards like Bagel and Schmear and Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur. Cards and sets like these serve to dilute the aesthetic identity of Magic, which I think is detrimental in the long run.

Story & Characters

Penance Stare | Illustration by Tulio Brito

In a similar vein, Universes Beyond also has some other baggage it carries with it. Because these are big IPs with lots of existing characters, you have to portray those characters on cards, which means sets with tons and tons of legendary creatures. However, this can be a bit detrimental to design, as legendary creatures create some design constraints. Additionally, the fact that so many creature slots in a set have to be dedicated to known characters means there’s less room to explore other things in the world, the things that form the background. There was a time where legendary creatures were much fewer and further between, and now it seems normal to get more than half the set as legends.

The result is a feeling of things being shoehorned in without much room to breath. The other effect is often an inability to tell stories through the cards. Since the IPs being drawn from often have been around for a long time and have several of their own disparate story lines with different characters, the set can’t cohesively tell a story. It can offer snippets and glimpses, but nothing that glues anything together. The big exception to this is Avatar: The Last Airbender, which by virtue of it being a concise show with a concise story arc, we get to experience that through the cards, and it makes it feel like a real lived in world with stakes rather than a hodge podge of stuff we may recognize.

Why Darkhold Is Different

The Darkhold | Illustration by Yohann Schepacz

These are the points where Universes Beyond falls short, these are the points where it doesn’t feel like Magic. However, it’s not without hope, and in fact, I believe the next Universes Beyond set Darkhold Destiny can and will fix these issues, and hopefully it will set a model for Universes Beyond going forward.

Darkhold Destiny is yet another Marvel themed set, but this time it will be focusing on the more fantastical elements of the super hero genre, specifically centering around Thor, Doctor Strange, and their villains. These are certainly the most high fantasy characters, and instead of New York, we’re also getting a more befitting setting. We’re low on details at the moment, but going off of the art we’ve seen so far, we won’t be seeing another Bagel and Schmear in this set.

Additionally, unlike other Universes Beyond sets up until this point which have relied on existing elements of the IP, Darkhold Destiny will be introducing a brand new original story that lines up with the set. This will help to make the world seem far more immersive and impactful, as the characters we see aren’t just cameo appearances, but rather active participants in the world.

Wrap Up

Hela, Mistress of Darkness | Illustration by Bastien L. Deharme

I think these changes are going to be far more impactful than they initially seem, and it will settle in once the set releases. There’s still a lot we don’t know, but it really looks like things are headed in the right direction with this set. As for future Universes Beyond sets, we know we’re getting two more in addition to Darkhold Destiny in 2027, although their names haven’t been announced yet.

My hope is that they adopt this approach if possible, where the choice of IP is one that can fit within the high fantasy aesthetic of Magic: The Gathering, and have characters and a story that make it feel like more than just a pile of references. Universes Beyond isn’t going anywhere anytime soon, so the best case scenario is a way to incorporate it that feels more natural, and this puts us on that path. Ultimately, we’ll just have to wait and see, but this certainly seems like a promising future for Magic.

Follow Draftsim for awesome articles and set updates:

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *