Last updated on November 17, 2026

The Madcap Jester | Illustration by Jesper Ejsing
As the holidays approach, it’s a good time to reflect on the year and what it’s offered us. In the small sphere of Magic, there’s a full eight sets to reflect on and consider. Here, I have 10 heavily underrated commanders (in my opinion), with a few rules:
- No reprints! The list only considers new-to-Magic commanders from 2026.
- “Underrated” in this case refers to commanders with fewer than 3,000 decklists on EDHREC at time of writing.
- This list is fairly subjective, so let me know what commanders you thought were overlooked in the comments!
#10. Baron Helmut Zemo – 2.79k decks
Given that Baron Helmut Zemo is hugging the upper boundary for my underrated range, it’s not the most underrated but I’d still love to see more people playing this. Conniving when you cast black spells keeps the cards flowing and enables graveyard synergies beyond the Baron’s boast trigger. Toss in that cost for devotion purposes and you have a grindy mono-black commander.
#9. The Madcap Jester – 2.05k decks
People might come around to The Madcap Jester as more MagicCons sell more Festivals in a Box and thus increase supply. For now, I’d say this is criminally underrated. Theft is fun but this is a great spin on it, and I love that it gives extraction effects, which are typically no good in Commander, a unique spin by making them tutors for your opponents’ decks. No other commander does this nonsense.
#8. Bilbo, Thief in the Night – 1.23k decks
Bilbo, Thief in the Night is a strong combo commander thanks to its place in the Sensei's Divining Top/Mystic Forge combo. But you can also play it fairly and have a pretty good time digging through the graveyard or messing with Future Sight effects… though I can see how that might be too narrow for some players.
#7. Invisible Woman – 1.17k decks
Invisible Woman has the perfect colors to exploit making a creature token each turn: You use token doublers, exploit toughness-matters cards, and trigger amazing token payoffs like Caretaker's Talent. I’m astonished an enabler for so many popular strategies isn’t more, well, popular, though I wonder how much that has to do with Universes Beyond fatigue….
#6. Iron Man, Bleeding Edge – 434 decks
Iron Man, Bleeding Edge was probably overlooked by most people in the slough of Marvel Super Heroes commanders, especially since it was in the MSH Jumpstart set. But I really like it. Copying an artifact you cast each turn spirals out of control in a way that feels very explosive and classically Commander. Making two Coveted Jewels into two copies of Portal to Phyrexia the next turn is just lovely.
#5. Mass of Mysteries – 2.51k decks
I understand why Mass of Mysteries faltered: It’s really hard to stand up to Ashling, the Limitless as an elemental commander. But I adore myriad. Elementals emphasis enters abilities, plus you can sacrifice the tokens after combat for even more value. Heck, this might even be the commander to break out the Arcane Adaptation for….
#4. Tom, Bert, and William – 2.14k decks
Tom, Bert, and William is a magnificent (if slow) power-matters commander that turns cards like Ghalta, Primal Hunger and Slumbering Trudge into more cards than you can handle. There are so many cool, explosive lines, and it even has built-in protection to survive removal. And it can only get better as Wizards keeps printing cards with ludciriously high power compared to their cost—the Trudge and Bebop & Rocksteady and Kalakscion, Hunger Tyrant have all come out within the last couple years.
#3. Don & Leo, Problem Solvers – 867 decks
Magic’s flooded with blink commanders but I think Don & Leo, Problem Solvers deserves a bigger slice of the pie than it’s getting. The archetype already wants Teleportation Circle and its ilk; why not cut those from the 99 and just run it in the command zone? I’m especially interested because of how many artifacts worth flickering exist, and I’m not just talking about artifact creatures like Riptide Gearhulk. Wizards keeps pumping out cards like Glimmer Lens, Cryogen Relic, and King Solomon's Frogs that keep pace with any creature flicker target.
#2. Karn, Gilded Guardian – 1.9k decks
Wizards has been printing colored artifacts long enough for Karn, Gilded Guardian to receive significant support, so I’m not sure why a 5-color commander with great card draw is so unpopular. Maybe it’s just lost out for being one of the last commanders in a year with so many sets. It’s also worth noting that, because of how hybrid mana works, Karn’s mana value is 10, which is wonderful for cards like Majestic Genesis and Cloudkill.
#1. Lyra, Tolarian Archangel – 1.17k decks
I love Lyra, Tolarian Archangel. A mono-blue angel commander that cares about card draw? Okay, so blue doesn’t have the angel synergies, but it cares about card draw and works well with flying creatures. And cards like Brainstorm and Brainsurge even let you make angels on opposing turns. It’s just such a fun mono-blue commander that doesn’t feel like the others.
Follow Draftsim for awesome articles and set updates:


Add Comment