Last updated on January 14, 2022

Pippa, Duchess of Dice - Illustration by Simon Dominic

Pippa, Duchess of Dice | Illustration by Simon Dominic

Whether you’re a new or seasoned gamer, you’re probably aware that dice are an integral part of paper Magic. With counters, a spindown life counter, and the recent addition of rolling a d20 introduced with the D&D set Forgotten Realms, you’ll always have a use for dice. And that’s not to mention how important dice are to many, many other games.

When it comes to buying your own set of dice, there are lots of options out there. It can be hard to figure out where to start narrowing down which ones are best for you. So you’ve decided to go with metal over plastic or resin dice. But once you’ve figured that out, you’ve only just barely started.

But worry not! I’ve scoured the internet for the best products when it comes to metal dice so that you don’t have to. How to find them, what to look for, the best in a few different categories.

If you just want to cut to the chase, my pick for best overall metal dice is Blacksmith’s Anvil Dice.

Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
  • COMPLETE SET OF QUALITY DICE: Complete set of 7 pieces, a 20/12/10/8/6, decader (00-99) and 4 sided dice. Its top quality FULL metal build that weighs up to 50% more than cheap plastic dice, will ensure you get the most out of your RPGs or math games.
  • PERFECT FOR YOUR ROLEPLAYING GAMES: Whether it’s a DnD gathering, a game of Pathfinder or Shadowrun or even Math games, this quality set of dice is ideal. Made with our own unique alloy blend down to its core, it will ensure that all your rolls are truly random so that you get the best roleplaying experience possible.
  • TOP NOTCH DESIGN: Our dice set features sharp corners for the best balance possible compared to curved cornered dice. The numbers are engraved, painted and centered, which makes them clear to read and ensures they’re not crowded. While industry standard size is 16mm, our set averages at 18mm with a d20 of 20mm.
  • A HISTORY OF QUALITY IN RPG ACCESSORIES: Norse Foundry stands for quality and is well celebrated in the industry. Making dice since 2011 using unique custom designs & molds offer only the best products that really set them apart. Upon purchasing our dice set, you get a Money Back Guarantee and free replacement in 30 days. You simply can’t go wrong with this deal.
  • CUSTOM COLORED SETS FOR A UNIQUE EXPERIENCE: Our dice sets come in a variety of colors to truly match your game’s atmosphere and put the ROLE part back into the Role Playing Games. With colors such as silver, gold, copper, bronze and black, you are bound to find the perfect ones no matter what adventure you’re setting off on.

Without further ado, let’s just jump right in!

Are Metal Dice Worth It?

Metalspinner's Puzzleknot - Illustration by Vincent Proce

Metalspinner’s Puzzleknot | Illustration by Vincent Proce

Metal dice are an investment in feel and fashion. Although they’re generally more precise than plastic sets, there isn’t much of a practical reason to get metal dice unless you’re playing at the highest level. The only practical advantage of metal dice is that they’re sturdier than plastic ones. This makes them ideal if you’re planning to get one set of dice and stick with it for years. Where plastic dice will bend and scratch, metal dice tend to stand the test of time.

Now, metal dice also have some other considerations. They’re generally quite a bit heavier than their plastic counterparts. This makes them a bit worse for frail-wristed users, as they can take a toll over a long time.

If you’re on a low budget, metal dice aren’t likely to be worth it. They’re quite a bit more expensive and don’t offer much of a functional advantage. On the other hand, their feel and aesthetics are a cut above even the best of plastic dice. They’re also unlikely to bounce around a lot and go off-table, so grab yourself a pair if you’re someone that has issues with that.

Top Pick
Best Overall
Best Budget Pick
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
Bescon Copper Solid Metal Polyhedral D&D Dice Set of 7 Copper Metallic RPG Role Playing Game Dice 7pcs Set D4-D20
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
Bescon Copper Solid Metal Polyhedral D&D Dice Set of 7 Copper Metallic RPG Role Playing Game Dice 7pcs Set D4-D20
Price not available
Price not available
Top Pick
Best Overall
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
Price not available
Best Budget Pick
Bescon Copper Solid Metal Polyhedral D&D Dice Set of 7 Copper Metallic RPG Role Playing Game Dice 7pcs Set D4-D20
Bescon Copper Solid Metal Polyhedral D&D Dice Set of 7 Copper Metallic RPG Role Playing Game Dice 7pcs Set D4-D20
Price not available

Buyer’s Guide: What to Consider

So, how do you tell good dice from bad dice? Here are just a few considerations.

Price

Blood Price - Illustration by Antonio José Manzanedo

Blood Price | Illustration by Antonio José Manzanedo

This is a bit controversial, but good dice tend to not be too cheap. Sure, there are budget sets of metal dice that offer a good amount of quality, but you’re unlikely to find a good set under $20 or a single die under $3.

On the other hand, there are also diminishing returns once you get to a very high price point. Sometimes more expensive dice might even be worse from a practical standpoint since more “exotic” materials often go against a die’s practicality. It’s pretty likely that your perfect pair will sit somewhere in the $25 to $70 range.

Precision

Obviously you don’t want dice that don’t roll properly. The precision of the set make can make or break your purchase. There are some dice that lean towards different numbers or sets of numbers because of flaws in their construction.

It’s relatively easy to check whether or not your dice are balanced with plastic dice, while it’s extremely difficult and time-consuming to do the same with metal ones. You’ll want to buy dice from a trusted brand to avoid the hassle.

Durability

Some dice can actually break pretty easily if rolled on the wrong surface. This applies to some less high-quality aluminum dice the most. The biggest challenge with metal dice, however, is scratching.

The surface you’re rolling on actually affects quite a bit when it comes to dice. You can easily test the durability of metal dice by trying to make a small scratch with your nail. If you can see the spot, the dice are probably prone to scratching. Some kinds of dice can also damage the table you’re playing on, so a rolling tray might be in order.

Size

Abundant Growth - Illustration by Vincent Proce

Abundant Growth | Illustration by Vincent Proce

Metal dice come in a variety of sizes, just like plastic ones. If you’re planning to use your dice as a life counter, getting a metal jumbo sized die (35mm+) can be a great idea. This makes it easier for both you and your opponent to clearly see your life total. If you’re planning to roll it, however, a die that large might hurt your wrist.

On the other end of the spectrum, there are dice around 10mm. These are generally impractical for MTG as they only really come in handy with huge token boards. If you play a deck like that, these might be your best option.

Aesthetic

There’s rarely a point to buying metal dice that you don’t like the look of. Whether you prefers pips or numerals, colored dice or pure metal ones, you should try to find dice that fit your style.

This is especially true for metal dice that are already priced at a premium. You don’t want to spend a Scalding Tarn on dice that you don’t like.

Types of Material for Metal Dice

Unsubstantiate - Illustration by Victor Adame Minguez

Unsubstantiate | Illustration by Victor Adame Minguez

There are a lot of factors that change based on the material of the dice you’re using. Some materials are cheaper, less durable, or might even just make a less satisfying sound. Here’s a rundown of some options and what to look out for with each.

Zinc Alloy Dice

Zinc dice generally undergo polishing, electrophoresis, coloring, and electroplating. Because of the number of processes that happen to make them, there’s a lot of room for error here. With that being said, it’s an excellent budget material for metal dice.

Tin Alloy Dice

Tin is a pretty soft metal. These dice are quite likely to dent and scratch because of tin’s softness so they’re unsuitable for MTG and role-playing games. They can be passable if you’re planning on using them as a spindown, but you should generally avoid them otherwise.

Aluminum Alloy Dice

Aluminum dice are generally high quality. They’re quite light which makes them great if you’re looking for metal dice that are less likely to affect your wrist. Their manufacturing process is more complicated, which means that it’s more likely that they’ll have production errors. It’s even more important to buy from a trusted retailer because of this. With that being said they’re quite sturdy, and some of the most precise dice are made with aluminum alloy.

Stainless Steel Dice

Stainless steel is heavy and doesn’t offer much plasticity. It’s used for more stylish dice that won’t get rolled too often. If you’re using these to mark down counters or track life instead of rolling, they’ll do just fine. They are a bit difficult to paint, though, so they generally offer a simpler look.

Titanium Alloy Dice

Titanium is usually used in the military and high-end manufacturing as a harder and lighter material than most other metals. Titanium is also really expensive, so you’ll rarely find these dice for an “affordable” price.

Where to Store Your Metal Dice

As a rule of thumb, you should keep your metal dice in a soft and dry container. Getting a dice mat or box can also significantly extend the lifespan of your dice. Even the best metal dice eventually succumb to the elements if you don’t take care of them.

It’s also important for you not to keep them in the same place as your plastic or resin dice, since metal dice are much harder and can easily dent their softer counterparts.

Where Should You Be Rolling?

The considerations when it comes to rolling your metal dice are twofold.

The first thing to consider is whether or not you’ll damage your surface by rolling your dice there. Metal dice can easily accumulate wear on a table made out of wood or another soft material.

The second is whether the dice themselves will be damaged by the surface. Metal dice are a lot more rigid than plastic ones, which makes them prone to damage from the surface itself.

The best way to roll your metal dice is on a rolling tray. This also prevents you from getting into situations where the die falls off the table while also preventing damage. If you don’t have one, using a surface like a mousepad, playmat, or a few sheets of paper can be enough to save your die, and the surface you’re rolling on, from damage.

The Cadillac of Metal Dice

Level Up Dice Tungsten Set

When it comes to selecting the best metal dice, it’ll always depend on what you prioritize. But the Level Up Dice Tungsten set is hard to beat when it comes to sheer quality. The set gives you all of the best dice for Magic aside from a spindown. And given that these dice are already dubbed the “table destroyers,” a spindown might just break your house.

Made by a reputable premium dice brand, Level Up Dice, this set weighs over 1 pound and is guaranteed to be quality. Sure, its $634 price tag is nothing to scoff at, but this is the one for you if you’re looking for a premium set of dice. They’re CNC machined with maximum precision to ensure that they roll accurately, and their numbers aren’t etched in to keep the solid metal look.

Pros

  • Surface damage is practically impossible to cause in one go, and it’ll accumulate extremely slowly regardless of how you roll them.
  • They’re made by a reputable company, ensuring the trustworthiness of a purchase like this.
  • They feel amazing if you’re someone that likes the heavy feel of metal dice. These are one of the heaviest around.
  • You can easily customize your pair since they’re unpainted.
  • They’re a great way to pimp out your dice collection.
  • The sound made when they’re rolled is akin to the firing of a tank.
  • They’re engineered for peak precision

Cons

  • They’re extremely expensive.
  • They aren’t safe for regular tables.
  • They might be too heavy for most users.

If you want something cheaper and prefer Amazon, here’s a set of two tungsten D6s:

The Best Metal Dice Overall

Blacksmith Anvil Dice Set

Not many would argue that getting a Cadillac is the best decision for your average Joe. Even without its price, it’s not the best car to drive to work in every day. In that same vein, the table destroyers up there might not be the best dice for your casual kitchen table Commander game.

With that in mind, the best dice set award has to go to the Blacksmith’s Anvil dice set from Norse Foundry. These are made by a company that has made metal dice their signature. They cover all of an MTG player’s needs.

They’re a bit bigger than normal, sitting at 18mm compared to the usual 16mm. This makes reading them just that little bit easier.

They aren’t too heavy either, so most people won’t have any trouble using these dice for more than just MTG. Even playing a TTRPG should be a painless breeze.

Pros

  • Relatively affordable given their quality.
  • The ideal weight. Heavy enough to feel them in your hand, but not too heavy as to leave permanent damage on most surfaces.
  • Extremely satisfying to roll.
  • Made with precision in mind so you never have to question the authenticity of a roll.
  • Slick, clean design that ensures easy readability.
  • 30-day money-back guarantee.

Cons

  • They aren’t very fancy-looking.
  • Softer surfaces might still suffer some damage with extensive use.
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
  • COMPLETE SET OF QUALITY DICE: Complete set of 7 pieces, a 20/12/10/8/6, decader (00-99) and 4 sided dice. Its top quality FULL metal build that weighs up to 50% more than cheap plastic dice, will ensure you get the most out of your RPGs or math games.
  • PERFECT FOR YOUR ROLEPLAYING GAMES: Whether it’s a DnD gathering, a game of Pathfinder or Shadowrun or even Math games, this quality set of dice is ideal. Made with our own unique alloy blend down to its core, it will ensure that all your rolls are truly random so that you get the best roleplaying experience possible.
  • TOP NOTCH DESIGN: Our dice set features sharp corners for the best balance possible compared to curved cornered dice. The numbers are engraved, painted and centered, which makes them clear to read and ensures they’re not crowded. While industry standard size is 16mm, our set averages at 18mm with a d20 of 20mm.
  • A HISTORY OF QUALITY IN RPG ACCESSORIES: Norse Foundry stands for quality and is well celebrated in the industry. Making dice since 2011 using unique custom designs & molds offer only the best products that really set them apart. Upon purchasing our dice set, you get a Money Back Guarantee and free replacement in 30 days. You simply can’t go wrong with this deal.
  • CUSTOM COLORED SETS FOR A UNIQUE EXPERIENCE: Our dice sets come in a variety of colors to truly match your game’s atmosphere and put the ROLE part back into the Role Playing Games. With colors such as silver, gold, copper, bronze and black, you are bound to find the perfect ones no matter what adventure you’re setting off on.

The Most Precise Metal Dice

Candy Collection GravityDice

Dice precision is notoriously hard to test and measure, especially with metal dice. But aluminum dice tend to come out on top on most measurements. The d6s over at Gravity Dice are definitely on top in this area. These dice scream class and precision.

With each pip of the dice drilled in a precise location, these dice have given their all to ensure maximum roll quality. They’re quite expensive for d6s, but these are the dice if you’re looking for that near-perfect randomness.

The Gravity Dice Polyhedral Dice collection is also great in case you need a larger variety, and they can hang with giants like Norse Foundry and Kraken Dice in this category.

Pros

  • The pips on these dice are drilled to a precise depth to make sure your dice are as balanced as possible.
  • Excellent clear coating to protect your dice from damage.
  • Chamfered edges ensure maximum randomness on each roll.
  • Clean and elegant look.

Cons

  • Quite expensive, especially if you’ll be using them just to track counters.
  • The d6s are a bit better than the rest of the dice.

The Best Budget Metal Die

Bescon Dice Copper Set

When it comes to budget metal dice, it’s easy to be blinded by a $5 or $7 set, but these generally won’t be fully metal, and if they are they’ll be low quality. You should be looking at zinc dice when shopping on a budget. Be aware that zinc can be quite soft. You should probably get a dice rolling tray or a soft surface to roll on to avoid damaging them.

A diamond in the rough is the Bescon Dice Copper Set. They’re made from cast copper, which is a lot more durable than zinc. They’ve also got that rustic charm. They’re not too heavy either, so they’re great if you’re looking for a set of metal dice to use with friends without breaking the bank.

Pros

  • They’re pretty cheap for the quality.
  • Copper is usually a better material for dice than zinc.
  • They’ve got a great aesthetic.
  • They’re not too heavy.

Cons

  • They’re easily outclassed by more quality-made dice.
  • They’re prone to being damaged when used on the wrong surface.

Weird and Unusual Metal Dice

Awesome Dice d1

While the above are shining examples of quality and precision, there’s something to be said about the sheer oddity factor of something like the Awesome Dice D1. This die is exactly what it says on the tin: a dice that hits a 1 every time you “roll” it.

Awesome Dice d3

There are some more practical weird dice out there, like the Awesome Dice D3. These are actually quite sturdy and have some niche applications in games outside of MTG. This design, although weird, tends to be more precise than the standard design.

Gothic Rosette d30 by Wombat

If you’d like to go all-out on the sheer intricacy of an unusual metal dice, this D30 might be just the thing for you.

RPG Dice Spinner by MythrollArmory

There are also some devices like this dice spinner that aren’t technically dice, but they perform the same purpose and can be extremely fun to use.

PolyHero Cleric dice

Although the dice over at PolyHero aren’t exactly metal, I thought they were simply too cool not to mention. They’re extremely stylized, mostly to look like objects an RPG character would use. Imagine how cool it would be to roll the Cleric set with your Soul Sisters deck?

PolyHero Dice: Rogue: Burglar’s Bundle (Grappling Hook, Rope, Skeleton Key)
  • The PolyHero Rogue Set Burglar’s Bundle is a 3-piece set that includes a D3 grappling hook, a D4 rope, and a D2 skeleton key.

Wrap Up

Rolling Stones - Illustration by Don Hazeltine

Rolling Stones | Illustration by Don Hazeltine

There’s a ton of variety when it comes to metal dice. From tungsten-made goliaths that might just break your table to cheap zinc dice. The best all around is the Blacksmith’s Anvil dice set thanks to its approachable price point, excellent construction, and precision.

Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
  • COMPLETE SET OF QUALITY DICE: Complete set of 7 pieces, a 20/12/10/8/6, decader (00-99) and 4 sided dice. Its top quality FULL metal build that weighs up to 50% more than cheap plastic dice, will ensure you get the most out of your RPGs or math games.
  • PERFECT FOR YOUR ROLEPLAYING GAMES: Whether it’s a DnD gathering, a game of Pathfinder or Shadowrun or even Math games, this quality set of dice is ideal. Made with our own unique alloy blend down to its core, it will ensure that all your rolls are truly random so that you get the best roleplaying experience possible.
  • TOP NOTCH DESIGN: Our dice set features sharp corners for the best balance possible compared to curved cornered dice. The numbers are engraved, painted and centered, which makes them clear to read and ensures they’re not crowded. While industry standard size is 16mm, our set averages at 18mm with a d20 of 20mm.
  • A HISTORY OF QUALITY IN RPG ACCESSORIES: Norse Foundry stands for quality and is well celebrated in the industry. Making dice since 2011 using unique custom designs & molds offer only the best products that really set them apart. Upon purchasing our dice set, you get a Money Back Guarantee and free replacement in 30 days. You simply can’t go wrong with this deal.
  • CUSTOM COLORED SETS FOR A UNIQUE EXPERIENCE: Our dice sets come in a variety of colors to truly match your game’s atmosphere and put the ROLE part back into the Role Playing Games. With colors such as silver, gold, copper, bronze and black, you are bound to find the perfect ones no matter what adventure you’re setting off on.

The biggest factor is that you keep your needs in mind when picking dice. You might like something a bit flashier than Blacksmith’s Anvil, or your budget might be closer to $100 to $200. Consider your options well. Metal dice can be a large investment, and having a good set can help with the feel of your game. They also make a great gift for the gamer in your life.

Top Pick
Best Overall
Best Budget Pick
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
Bescon Copper Solid Metal Polyhedral D&D Dice Set of 7 Copper Metallic RPG Role Playing Game Dice 7pcs Set D4-D20
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
Bescon Copper Solid Metal Polyhedral D&D Dice Set of 7 Copper Metallic RPG Role Playing Game Dice 7pcs Set D4-D20
Price not available
Price not available
Top Pick
Best Overall
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
Set of 7 Blacksmiths Anvil Full Metal Polyhedral Dice by Norse Foundry | RPG Math Games DND Pathfinder
Price not available
Best Budget Pick
Bescon Copper Solid Metal Polyhedral D&D Dice Set of 7 Copper Metallic RPG Role Playing Game Dice 7pcs Set D4-D20
Bescon Copper Solid Metal Polyhedral D&D Dice Set of 7 Copper Metallic RPG Role Playing Game Dice 7pcs Set D4-D20
Price not available

Did we miss your favorite dice? What’s the biggest thing you consider when purchasing metal dice? Let us know in the comments below!

Note: this post contains affiliate links. If you use these links to make a purchase, you’ll help Draftsim continue to provide awesome free articles and apps.

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *