Last updated on November 16, 2026

The Commander Format Panel, the managing body of Magic’s most popular format, has their final chance to ban (or unban) cards is in just two weeks on November 30th. Rhystic Study is one of the most popular cards in both competitive and casual decks being represented in nearly 1/4 in all decks according to EDHREC.
Since the format panel released sweeping, controversial bans last year on major players like Dockside Extortionist and Jeweled Lotus, cards specifically designed for the format thaw similar play rates to Rhystic Study, players have speculated heavily on the fate of one of the most popular blue card in Magic.
What Does Wizards Say?
We sat down with Gavin Verhey, Principal Magic Designer at Wizards of the Coast, at MagicCon Atlanta to discuss the Commander format, and one of the first questions that came up was, “how are our studies going?”
Gavin is always as direct as he is allowed to be, which is greatly appreciated. While he didn’t give a firm yes or no answer, instead mentioning that any decisions this year will come in two weeks, he did lay out their thinking regarding bans in commander and how they affect the greater playerbase and their strategies.
“The bar to ban in commander is very high,” Verhey said.
“In CEDH play [rhystic study] is a dominating force… it’s the card that many games revolve around. In casual, it’s a also very popular card to play. Banning that would be a very large blow to people’s decks and collections.”
I got the impression that Gavin, and the format panel, have shifted to weighing the effect of banning popular cards much more seriously than last year when they banned Dockside and Jeweled Lotus.
Does Rhystic Study Deserve To Be Banned?

Rhystic Study | Illustration by Fuzichoco
Rhystic Study is certainly as prominent as previously banned Commander cards. It’s in practically every single deck that plays blue, regardless of strategy or pace. It also creates major restrictions on every player on the table through a card type, enchantment, that isn’t as easily removed as creatures.
Just like Dockside, it generates huge material advantages regardless of whether players facing it pay the 1 or not. And more similarly to dockside, standard creature removal, the most prominent type, is ineffective. Counterspell is going to the the most effective, but unlike Dockside’s ETB effect, there is a window to remove the effect after the spell has resolved.
Jeweled Lotus, however, can be played as early as turn 1 and presents a much larger, immediate problem in casual play. There can be zero room for response and recovery, unlike Rhystic which is much more difficult to play on turn 1 (and not nearly as effective).
And similar to both cards, Rhystic Study is as popular as they come. Banning the card would have sweeping effects on both casual and competitive players without removing nearly as oppressive and interactive effect. That disparity is likely going to be the saving grace for the popular enchantment when it’s fate is decided in two weeks.
When the ban list is out, we’ll be the first to report on it, so stay tuned.
Follow Draftsim for awesome articles and set updates:







Add Comment